(The Ithaca Times, 09-18-25, by Matt Dougherty)
Despite polling showing that the 2024 presidential race was a toss up, Donald Trump increased his share of votes among several key demographic groups and won every single swing state as well as the popular vote. In response, Indivisible Tompkins was established to inform residents about their rights to protest and pressure local elected officials to stand in opposition to the Trump administration instead of caving to its demands.
Trump’s victory in 2016 saw immediate resistance from the entirety of the Democratic Party, but his victory in 2024 saw more demoralization among Democratic voters and capitulation from Democratic politicians.
A post-election survey from the Pew Research Center found that “pessimism” about the future of the Democratic Party is now “higher than at any point over the last eight years.” The survey also found that the public believed the Republican Party represented the interests of “people like them” more than the Democratic Party for the first time since 2016. According to polling from Gallup, the Democratic Party’s current approval rating is at a record low of 34%. When Democrats first lost to Trump in 2016 the party’s approval rating was 45%.
Due to these trends, a number of Democratic politicians responded to Trump’s victory by moving to the right on issues such as immigration and transgender rights.
A total of 60 Democrats in Congress voted to pass Trump’s first immigration related bill, the Laken Riley Act, which granted authority to federal immigration agencies to detain undocumented residents without being convicted of a crime. It’s a policy that has resulted in an estimated 70% of people detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) lacking a criminal record. Democratic representatives Tom Suozzi and Seth Moulton have also criticized their party for “pandering to the far-left” on issues regarding trans rights.
Most of the reporting in the immediate aftermath of the election focused on the public’s burnout regarding Trump-related crises and speculated about the potential for the administration to take authoritarian measures to crack down on any opposition — like deploying the National Guard in blue cities like Washington DC, Los Angeles and Chicago — which has now become reality.
Indivisible Tompkins was founded as a local chapter of the national Indivisible movement for collective action, intended to use local organizing to pressure elected officials to resist Trump’s agenda.
“Indivisible Tompkins was founded in February 2025 because there was so much local outrage and desire to take meaningful, impactful action to stop the harm being done by the Trump administration,” said Emily Adams, a member of the group’s steering committee. “We knew that organizing under Indivisible would bring us into a community of powerful organizers, all dedicated to saving democracy and defeating MAGA.”
Adams says the group aims to take strategic action through “advocacy and electoral activism,” with one of their primary goals being to “take back the House in 2026 to stop the cruelty, hate and harm being done by the MAGA agenda.”
Despite being a new group in town, Indivisible Tompkins is already impacting local political organizing. For the last several months, they have organized recurring weekly protests along Route 13 and on the Commons to draw attention to the ways in which they claim the Trump administration is undermining American democracy. They have been vocal opponents against ICE raids, federal funding cuts and mass layoffs enacted by the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE). They were the main organizers behind the Hands Off protest on April 5 and the massive No Kings protest on June 14 that saw an estimated 4,000 people flood the streets of Ithaca.
These organizing efforts have been successful at attracting local attention to the impacts of national decision-making and encouraging local elected officials to take a stance against the administration. But they haven’t been able to stop the Trump administration from implementing policies that violate the constitution and passing unpopular legislation that cuts trillions of dollars in social spending on health care and food assistance to give trillions of dollars in tax cuts to the rich. As a result, Indivisible Tompkins and the national Indivisible movement have decided to alter their tactics in the hopes of having a greater impact.
Adams said that the national Indivisible organization is completing a six-week training course to bring experts in political science, labor, and organizing together to discuss what national strategic non-cooperation looks like.
“Indivisible National recently launched the One Million Rising campaign, designed to help teach non-cooperation strategies to one million people,” Adams said. “We had members of Indivisible Tompkins attend, be trained, and we’re beginning our organizing efforts to see what actions we can take locally that could make an impact.” She added, “the goal right now is to train a million people across the country to participate in strategic non-cooperation.”
Adams said these non-cooperation strategies could involve ICE agents refusing to participate in raids, or even cafeteria and janitorial workers at detention centers refusing to work.
“The goal nationally and locally is to move into tactics where we can have a direct effect on gumming up the works of the unlawful and cruel actions of this administration,” Adams said.
Even though some tactics are changing, the group maintains a presence in the community. On Aug. 6, they organized an event at the Bernie Milton Pavillion to celebrate the 60th anniversary of the Voting Rights Act and conduct voter-registration training ahead of a weeklong voter-registration drive. They’re also in the process of planning another No Kings Rally for Oct. 18.
“This will be another large mass-mobilization event at Washington Park,” Adams said. “Our various teams will be meeting before October 18th to prepare street art, hold safety training, and take other timely actions.” Among these is a campaign to pressure Democrats in Congress to use the upcoming Sept. 30 government funding deadline as leverage to force Republicans to act in a bipartisan manner to avoid a government shutdown.
For the government to remain open beyond Sept. 30 the Senate must pass a spending bill, which because of the filibuster requires 60 votes to pass. Due to the slim margins in the Senate, Democrats will need to supply at least eight votes for any legislation to pass to avoid a government shutdown. The last time this opportunity emerged in March, both of New York’s Senators, along with eight other Democrats, voted with Republicans to pass a continuing resolution to keep the government open despite not getting any concessions.
This decision enabled the Trump administration to dismantle the democratic institutions of government by using legally dubious Presidential authorities to usurp congressional powers over spending and taxation. It has allowed the administration to implement immigration policies that violate the constitution while dismantling federal agencies like the Department of Education, National Labor Relations Board and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Keeping the government open also cleared the way for the administration to pass the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, significantly cutting social spending, extending tax cuts for the rich and increasing spending on immigration enforcement to historic levels.
In the six months since that continuing resolution was approved the Trump administration hasn’t shown any signs that it plans on stopping its abuses of power. In fact, it has doubled down on them, using the powers of the Presidency to deploy the National Guard in Democrat controlled cities that threaten opposition. As a result, a growing number of Democratic voters have begun to call on their party leaders to do more to oppose the Trump administration.
Indivisible Tompkins membership committee chair Ken Mckinney has said, “the general feeling within Indivisible is that the Democratic leadership is not doing enough. […] We would like to see broader, more outright opposition from Congress.”
Adams said that Indivisible Tompkins is urging their members to contact New York Senators Chuck Schumer and Kristen Gillibrand to ask them to withhold their vote on the Sept. 30 government funding deadline “unless the Republicans restore healthcare and rein in Trump’s lawlessness.”
This message has been received by Democrats like Schumer, who say they are now willing to risk a government shutdown unless Republicans agree to some form of extension for Affordable Care Act subsidies that expire at the end of the year. The expiration of ACA subsidies is estimated to increase insurance costs for some by 75% or more.
While shutting down the government indefinitely with no clear exit strategy is a risky move, Schumer told PBS “It will get worse with or without it, because Trump is lawless.”
Similarly, Adams said, “It’s not a good thing to let the government shutdown but in this case the alternative is probably worse.” She added, “I hope that Democrats can stand strong and use their leverage to get concessions.”
However, some say the party should push for more meaningful concessions than a short term extension of health care subsidies. “Participating in government funding in exchange for a short-term extension would, in a word, be madness,” wrote David Dayen, Executive Editor at The American Prospect. “Republicans want both to pass a budget and to avoid the heat for the crumbling of American health care; in this trade they would get both!”
Dayen continued saying that Democrats risk weakening their political leverage if they agree to a short-term extension of health care subsidies. He argued that such a deal would let Republicans avoid blame for pushing the system toward collapse and allow Trump to claim credit for keeping costs down, undermining Democrats’ advantage on an issue where they hold broad public support.
“Republicans willingly drove the health care system toward the point of oblivion, and some may question why Democrats would offer a lifeline to bail them out,” Dayen said.
Indivisible Tompkins believes that the country is in a time of authoritarian breakthrough, Adams said.
“All Democrats, and everyone who believes in democracy, needs to unite and to mobilize all their resources,” she said. “We need everyone to speak up, contact their elected officials, and prepare to vote in upcoming elections. […] Now is the time for Democratic politicians to be courageous leaders that lead by example and meet as frequently as possible with constituents to give them courage and motivation.”
While Adams thanked members of the Tompkins County Democratic Committee for “being strong allies” in resisting the Trump agenda, she said that Indivisible would like to see members of the Democratic Party in other areas and at the state and national level do more to resist the Trump agenda.
When asked if Indivisible thinks the Democratic party needs to be more progressive to effectively oppose Trump, Adams said, “The party needs to evolve for the times we are in. The labels of ‘moderate’ and ‘progressive’ don’t mean very much these days, because everything seems to come down to kitchen table issues.” She added, “Huge numbers of people have immediate economic insecurity, high levels of anxiety and they are looking for leaders who are listening. We stand with workers, families, seniors and those in vulnerable communities, over billionaires and corporations. We believe in a message of shared responsibility and prosperity.”
Adams continued saying that Indivisible has found it more useful to organize around general values rather than specific policy goals.
“We find it’s more useful to talk about our values [because] policy details change constantly, while our values do not,” Adams said. “We value peace, freedom, justice, responsibility, bringing people together, welcoming and including those who have been left behind, and taking care of children, the environment, and society as a whole.”
The group is advocating for some specific demands at the state level, including asking Governor Kathy Hochul to call a special session in Albany to address the “looming budget gap caused by the Republican cuts to Medicaid and other vital care programs,” Adams said.
“Albany needs to hold a special session to discuss taxing the super wealthy in New York, protecting those who are being targeted by ICE, and passing the New York Health Act,” she added.
Despite polling showing that 74% of New Yorkers support increasing taxes on the state’s wealthiest residents and 90% of Democratic voters support having the government ensure that all Americans have health care coverage, Gov. Houchul has refused to support increasing taxes on the wealthy or the New York Health Act, which would create a universal single-payer health care system in the state. However, she did recently endorse New York City Democratic Mayoral nominee Zohran Mamdani, who supports both of those policies.
When asked if Democrats risk losing elections by not supporting policies favored by majorities of their base, Adams said, “We know that big money in politics is a huge contributor to people feeling disengaged from the voting process and from democracy in general [and] we encourage voters to support candidates who don’t take corporate PAC money or AIPAC money and who want to tax the super rich.” She added, “Democrats can win more elections by adopting economic populist messages that also focus on fairness, freedom, and ending corruption.”
Adams said Democrats should campaign on themes that resonate with a broad base of voters, such as healthcare, housing, affordability, education, childcare, and transportation.
“Democrats should be pointing out that they are the party of freedom and opportunity, not the party of corruption and greed,” she said. “Democrats also need to make room for new energetic candidates with charisma and fresh ideas. As an Indivisible group, we are looking to support candidates who have these messages and these qualities.”
According to Adams, democratic candidates who want to win elections need to learn how to “feel the pain” of their constituents. She said these characteristics “seem to have more influence over how someone votes than actual policy positions.”


